Advertisement

Grade the trade: Suns make baffling decision to move for often-injured center

But why?
Luke Duffy
Luke Duffy

Valley of the Suns

Mercury owner Mat Ishbia announces the Ring of Honor proceedings during the home opener at the Footprint Center on Saturday, May 18, 2024. / Patrick Breen/The Republic / USA TODAY NETWORK

The Phoenix Suns were active on the night of the first round of the NBA Draft, as they added a pair of centers to their roster. The first was Khaman Maluach - taken 10th overall using the pick they got from the Houston Rockets in the Kevin Durant deal - with the 18-year-old joining with both a ton of risk and upside.

In a more perplexing move, the front office then decided to trade a first round pick in 2029 - plus the 29th pick in this draft which turned into Liam McNeeley - in order to acquire Mark Williams from the Charlotte Hornets. On paper the bruising 23-year-old is everything the Suns need - but unfortunately for the franchise - the game is not played on paper.

Suns have put all their eggs in the wrong center basket with trade.

Williams has been limited to only 106 games played for Charlotte across three seasons, although he did manage a double-double (15.3 points and 10.2 boards) in 44 games last season. The first part of that sentence is excellent, and it is exactly what the Suns have been lacking since they moved on from Deandre Ayton.

Williams is a hulking big who can protect the rim but also has some offensive game in the paint, with an effective field goal percentage for his career of over 62 percent. But in playing only 44 times - starting on 41 occasions - already it feels like Williams doesn't have the body to play for an entire regular season.

Which is a problem - because as Sam Presti has already painfully pointed out - the Suns don't have the depth to carry them through a regular season. That was a huge issue during the Durant era, and it is not something that looks to be getting better with the Williams acquisition. The Suns are betting that Williams can be healthy when it really counts, but that is a massive risk.

Why they went all in on him is confusing, because other centers are sure to become available for the right price as the summer unfolds. Being in the second apron doesn't help - which is why the Hornets took back Vasilije Micić in the deal - but this still feels like a massive stretch. It would make sense that the franchise would want another big with some experience after drafting Maluach.

But doubling up on Hornets centers - the Suns also traded for backup Nick Richards at the trade deadline - does not seem like the right direction for the franchise to be heading. Maluach is years away from being a consistent contributor - if he ever gets there at all - yet right now he feels like a safer bet than Williams. That's all you need to know and why this trade is yet another mess.

Final Grade: D-

Luke Duffy

Luke Duffy

Luke is the site expert for Valley of the Suns. He covers the NBA from Dublin, Ireland, and has been following the league closely since 2006. He previously wrote for Hoops Habit and was a site co-expert at Orlando Magic Daily before taking on sole responsibility of covering the Suns. Luke has a degree in journalism, has completed a course in sports psychology, and has had his work published in places including Fox Sports and The42. Away from basketball, he writes and edits scripts for filmmakers in Ireland and coaches a women's basketball team in Dublin.